It has been estimated that about 30-60% of online content that exists today, has not been created by humans – So..
..is the Internet Already Dead?
Have you ever scrolled through social media and felt like something was… off? Are you being sold dreams by people who don’t exist? Maybe the comments all sound the same. The posts seem strangely repetitive. The “people” you interact with don’t quite feel real.
Welcome to the Dead Internet Theory — a haunting idea that suggests much of the web we use today isn’t alive at all. Have you ever heard of ‘Dead Internet Theory’?
What Is the Dead Internet Theory?
The Dead Internet Theory claims that most online content is no longer created by humans, but by bots, AI systems, and automated scripts.
According to its followers, sometime around the mid-2010s, the internet quietly “died.” The messy, unpredictable conversations that once filled forums and comment threads were replaced by algorithmically generated noise.
In this view, today’s internet isn’t a community — it’s a simulation. It looks real, but it’s built to keep you scrolling, buying, and believing you’re still surrounded by people.
The Rise of the Synthetic Web
What you see when you look around?
- Bots and automated accounts dominate social platforms, pushing trends and content that no one actually made.
- AI-generated avatars with perfect smiles and flawless lives — are now promoting products on Instagram and TikTok. They don’t exist, yet they sell us clothes, diets, and dreams.
- Ebooks, articles, and blog posts are increasingly written by AI tools, uploaded in bulk, and sold automatically without a single human touch.
It’s seems to be a self-sustaining loop — AI creating content for AI-driven algorithms to recommend to human users, who can barely tell what’s real anymore. And the result? A digital world full of activity, but short on authenticity.
The Feeling of Digital Alienation
Even if the internet isn’t literally “dead,” many of us feel disconnected from it.
We scroll through feeds filled with perfect faces, perfect homes, perfect lives — all curated by algorithms or fabricated entirely by AI. And somehow, instead of connection that we all long, we feel emptier.
That’s the quiet tragedy of modern life online: we’re surrounded by endless “content” but starving for human presence.
The Dead Internet Theory, at its core, isn’t about conspiracy — it’s about loneliness. It captures how technology that once promised connection now leaves us isolated in a flood of automated useless noise.
When AI Becomes the Author of Everything
The commercialization of AI deepens this divide. AI-written e-books flood marketplaces, ghostwritten blogs fill search results, and synthetic influencers push products that no one genuinely cares about. The human touch — the quirks, mistakes, emotions that make stories real — gets lost. We’re not just losing trust in the internet; we’re losing our sense of reality within it.
The Real-Life Case: A Family, a Mushroom Book, and AI Gone Wrong
Here’s where theory collides with real danger
A family in the UK bought what they believed was a legitimate foraging guide titled something like “Mushrooms UK: A Guide to Harvesting Safe and Edible Mushrooms”. It was purchased from a major online retailer as a birthday gift and was meant to help them safely pick wild mushrooms. (Pop Inquirer)
Tragically, after following the book’s guidance, the family picked and ate mushrooms that turned out to be poisonous — leading them all to be hospitalised (The Deep View)
Upon inspecting the book more closely, the family found numerous red flags:
- The images looked suspiciously generated by AI. (Reddit)
- The text contained odd phrasing like: “In conclusion, morels are delicious mushrooms which can be consumed from August to the end of Summer. accompanied by a typical AI phrase: Let me know if there is anything else I can help you with.” (Reddit)
- The “author” appeared to have no real online presence or credibility; key background details were missing. (The Deep View)
Experts commented that this case underscores the serious risk: when AI-generated content masquerades as expert guidance — especially in high-risk domains (like mushroom foraging) — the consequences can be life-threatening. (Futurism)
The takeaway? It’s not only about boring misinformation — this is content that can harm. It shows how the “dead internet” idea isn’t just metaphorical: when authenticity goes missing, harm can follow.
Maybe the Internet Isn’t Dead — Just Hollow?
The internet might not be dead, but it’s definitely changing.
Automation isn’t inherently evil — it’s a tool. But when the pursuit of clicks and sales replaces real creativity, what’s left feels hollow.
Perhaps the challenge now is to bring life back to the web: to make space for real people, real thoughts, and real connection.
Because if we don’t, the “dead internet” won’t just be a theory — it’ll be the world we live in.
To prove this theory wrong, feel free to share your thoughts on what you have read 🙂 And follow this blog for more content about AI, automation, self-development and passive income ideas.
I work as a full time eProcurement/automation Lead in my professional capacity, also take part in various workshops and courses (mainly those led by human specialists in their areas) to get better understanding or where we are heading in this new digital reality. I will be happy if you join me in this exciting, yet sometimes a bit scary journey. Scroll down to the bottom to subscribe for more!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What is the Dead Internet Theory?
The Dead Internet Theory suggests that much of today’s online content is no longer created by humans but by AI systems, bots, and automation. It argues that sometime around the mid-2010s, the internet “died,” and what we see now is a simulation built to manipulate engagement and consumption.
Q2: Is the Dead Internet Theory true?
There’s no concrete proof that the internet is entirely “dead.” However, many online spaces are indeed dominated by bot activity, AI-generated text, and algorithmic amplification, which makes the web feel less human and more artificial.
Q3: How much of the internet is believed to be AI-generated?
Estimates vary, but analysts suggest that anywhere from 30% to over 60% of all web content may already be AI-generated or automated in some form.
That includes spam blogs, fake reviews, AI-written product descriptions, and auto-generated social media posts. As generative AI tools become easier to use, that percentage is expected to rise sharply in the coming years.
Q4: Why does the internet feel less authentic today?
Social media algorithms, AI content farms, and marketing automation have replaced much of the spontaneous, community-driven content that defined the early web. This has led to a sense of digital alienation — being surrounded by content, yet disconnected from real human voices.
Q5: What’s the story about the family poisoned by an AI-generated mushroom book?
A family in the UK was hospitalized after following instructions from an AI-generated mushroom-foraging eBook purchased online. The book contained false information about edible mushrooms, leading to accidental poisoning. The case highlights how AI-written material without expert review can be dangerous in real-world situations.
Q6: How can I tell if content is AI-generated?
Look for clues like:
- Repetitive or oddly phrased sentences
- Unnatural transitions or “assistant-like” tone
- Missing author credentials or unverifiable sources
- Generic stock images or AI-rendered visuals
If something feels off — trust your instincts and double-check information elsewhere.
Q7: How can we keep the internet “alive”?
By supporting real creators and verifying what we consume.
Engage with genuine communities, read from trusted sources, and be cautious of faceless brands or books that seem too perfect or vague. The web stays alive when humans keep creating with honesty and care.
Q8: What does DEAD INTERNET THEORY mean for the future?
AI will continue shaping the internet — but whether it replaces or enhances human creativity depends on how responsibly we use it. The choice isn’t between a living or dead internet — it’s between a human or hollow one.
Discover more from In The Loop
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
